Remember when the Los Angeles Lakers traded Vlade Divac for a high school kid named Kobe Bryant back in 1996? At the time, Kobe was only 17 years old. Few people anticipated the seismic impact that trade would have on the league. Divac was a proven NBA center who averaged around 12 points and 8 rebounds per game, but Kobe ended up winning five championships with the Lakers. The trade turned out to be one of the biggest fleeces in NBA history, but it wasn't without controversy. The Charlotte Hornets, who traded Kobe, still catch flak for that move to this very day. Imagine passing on one of the greatest players of all time for a solid, but not spectacular, big man.
Then there's the whole situation with Chris Paul in 2011. The New Orleans Hornets agreed to a deal that would send CP3 to the Lakers. In return, the Hornets would get Lamar Odom, Kevin Martin, and Luis Scola. The NBA, which actually owned the Hornets at the time due to financial problems, vetoed the trade, citing "basketball reasons". Fans and analysts were puzzled. Why would the NBA block a trade that seemed to benefit both sides? The answer lies in league politics; the NBA didn't want a super-team, especially one led by stars like Kobe and Paul. A similar trade then sent Paul to the Clippers, and though it worked out well for the Clips, it's impossible not to wonder what could have been.
In 2004, the blockbuster trade involving Shaquille O'Neal saw him leave the Lakers for the Miami Heat. Shaq, at 32 years old, was still a dominant force in the league, averaging 21.5 points and 11.5 rebounds per game. In return, the Lakers received Caron Butler, Lamar Odom, Brian Grant, and a first-round draft pick. Many thought the Lakers got fleeced, but they got some solid players, and the Heat won a championship in 2006 with Shaq and Dwyane Wade. Nevertheless, the sheer scale of Shaq's talent made this trade a hot topic among fans and analysts alike.
Another divisive trade was the 2007 deal that sent then six-time All-Star Kevin Garnett from the Minnesota Timberwolves to the Boston Celtics. The Celtics gave up Al Jefferson, Ryan Gomes, Sebastian Telfair, Gerald Green, Theo Ratliff, and two first-round picks. Fans and pundits criticized the Timberwolves for not getting enough in return for Garnett, who immediately helped the Celtics capture their first championship in 22 years. The Timberwolves endured years of mediocrity, accentuating the disparity in the trade's immediate impact.
Remember the infamous trade between the Brooklyn Nets and the Boston Celtics in 2013? The Nets mortgaged their future by trading for aging stars Paul Pierce and Kevin Garnett, giving up a whopping three first-round picks and the right to swap another. With Pierce at 36 and Garnett at 37, many questioned if it was worth the heavy price. Fast forward a few years, and the Celtics used those draft picks to build a young core, including stars like Jaylen Brown and Jayson Tatum. The Nets, on the other hand, fell into a rebuild that lasted several seasons. The lopsided outcome of this trade continues to haunt Brooklyn.
Let's not forget the trade that sent Carmelo Anthony from the Denver Nuggets to the New York Knicks in 2011. The Knicks sent Danilo Gallinari, Wilson Chandler, Raymond Felton, Timofey Mozgov, and a plethora of draft picks to Denver. Melo was undoubtedly a superstar, averaging over 25 points per game, but the Knicks gave up most of their depth and future assets. Denver, meanwhile, built a balanced roster around players they acquired. While Melo provided scoring bursts, the Knicks couldn't translate it into deep playoff runs. Fans and analysts argue whether the price New York paid was too high for Carmelo's services.
And who can ignore the trade that sent Luka Dončić to the Dallas Mavericks in exchange for Trae Young during the 2018 NBA Draft? Atlanta Hawks received Young and a future first-round pick. While both players have become stars, Luka's all-around game and potential MVP-caliber play have made many think Dallas won this trade hands down. But Trae Young’s electrifying style and deep shooting range keep this debate alive. As of 2023, Luka averages 27.4 points per game, while Trae averages 25.3, making this one of those swaps that will be analyzed for years.
In terms of under-the-radar deals, you can't ignore the 2001 trade that sent Jason Kidd from the Phoenix Suns to the New Jersey Nets for Stephon Marbury. At the time, both were top-tier point guards, but Kidd led the Nets to back-to-back Finals appearances in '02 and '03. Marbury, although talented, never achieved similar success, not even making it past the first round of the playoffs with Phoenix. Here, the contrast in team success underscored the brilliance involved in selecting the right leader.
All these stories and many more are why NBA trades remain an endlessly fascinating part of the sport. Each move carries a mix of risk, strategy, and sometimes a bit of luck. But when it comes to controversial trades, every fan has their theories, opinions, and “what if” scenarios that keep the conversations going year after year.
For more insightful stories about the world of sports, click on this arena plus.